Between war and peace: the uncertain fate of Napoleonic prisoners of war
Forrest Alan
From Iberia to Russia, in the colonies and at sea, thousands of French soldiers were taken prisoner during the Napoleonic Wars. What fate awaited them in captivity? There were no legally enforceable international conventions of the sort that began to appear in the later nineteenth century. The terms of any surrender were often left to the generals in the field, though they knew that it was in their interest to show some mercy since the fate of their own men might depend on their decisions. Nonetheless, the terms imposed varied hugely. A lucky few might hope to be the subject of prisoner exchanges. Officers could expect to be paroled in approved towns where they were on their honour not to escape. Other ranks were less fortunate, and were usually held in prisons, in secure camps, or offshore on hulks. The article gives particular attention to the conditions in which French prisoners were held in Britain during the war years.
References:
Aguilera-Mellado P. The Goyesque Gaze: Image, Violence, Dignity-Potency // Hispanic Research Journal. 2019. N 20:5. P. 491-514.
Anderson М. War and Society in Europe of the Old Regime, 1618-1789. Leicester, 1988.
Asch R.G. «Wo der soldat hinkombt, da ist alles sein»: Military violence and atrocities in the Thirty Years War re-examined // German History. 2000. N 18:3. P. 291-309.
Astbury К. «Whole Shew and Spectacle»: French Prisoner-of-War Theatre in England during the Napoleonic Era // Journal of War & Culture Studies. 2021. N 14:2. P. 194-210.
Bernard L. Les prisonniers de guerre du Premier Empire. Paris, 2000.
Best G. Humanity in warfare: the modern history of the international law of armed conflicts. London, 1980.
Best G. Nuremberg and After: the continuing history of war crimes and crimes against humanity: The Stenton Lecture, 1983. Reading, 1984.
Boudon J.-O. Postface // Smith D. Les soldats oubliés de Napoléon, 1809-1814. Prisonniers sur l’île de Cabrera. Paris, 2005.
Breton A.-D. H. Lettres de ma captivité en Russie // Combats et captivité en Russie. Mémoires et lettres de soldats français. Paris, 1999.
Brown G.D. Prisoner of war parole: ancient concept, modern utility // Military Law Review. 1998. N 156.
Burrows Е. Forgotten Patriots: The Untold Story of American Prisoners During the Revolutionary War. New York, 2008.
Burton D. Napoleonic Prisoners of War in Chesterfield // Derbyshire Record Office Blog, 19 July 2022. URL: https://recordoffice.wordpress.com/2022/07/19/napoleonic-prisoners-of-war-in-chesterfield (дата обращения: 7 мая 2023 г.).
Cartel for the exchange of prisoners of war between Great Britain and the United States of America // Documents on Prisoners of War / Ed. by H.S. Levie // International Law Studies. 1979. Vol. 60.
Chamberlain Р. The Napoleonic Prison of Norman Cross. The Lost Town of Huntingdonshire. Stroud, 2018.
Childs J. Surrender and the Laws of War in Western Europe, c. 1660-1783 // How Fighting Ends. / Ed. by H. Afflerbach, H. Strachan. Oxford, 2012.
Colson В. Napoleon on War. Oxford, 2015.
Corvisier A. Préface // Quoy-Bodin J.-L. L’armée et la franc-maçonnerie, au déclin de la monarchie, sous la Révolution et l’Empire. Paris, 1987.
Daly G. Napoleon’s Lost Legions: French Prisoners of War in Britain, 1803 – 1814 // History 2004.
Duché E. L’otium des captifs d'honneur britanniques à Verdun sous le Premier Empire, 1803-1814 // Arrachés et déplacés. Réfugiés politiques, prisonniers de guerre, déportés, 1789-1918 / Éd. par N. Beaupré, K. Rance. Clermont-Ferrand, 2016.
Duché E. Prisoners of war // The Cambridge History of the Napoleonic Wars / Ed. by A. Forrest, P. Hicks. Vol. 3: Experience, Culture and Memory. Cambridge, 2022.
Dwyer P. «It still makes me shudder»: Memories of Massacres and Atrocities during the Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars // War in History. 2009. N 16:4.
Dzurec D. Prisoners of War and American Self-image during the American Revolution // War in History. 2013. N 20.
Elliot W. The French in Selkirk, 1811-1814. Galashiels: Ettrick and Lauderdale District Council Museum Service, 1982.
Espinosa P. The horrors of Cádiz’s floating jails // El País, 31 July 2014.
Forrest А. Prisonniers de guerre et récits de captivité dans les guerres napoléoniennes // Arrachés et déplacés. Réfugiés politiques, prisonniers de guerre, déportés, 1789-1918 / Éd. par N. Beaupré, K. Rance. Clermont-Ferrand, 2016.
Garneray L. The floating prison: the remarkable account of nine years' captivity on the British prison hulks during the Napoleonic Wars, 1806 -1814. London, 2003.
Gille P. Les Prisonniers de Cabrera. Mémoires d'un conscrit de 1808, recueillis et publiés par Philippe Gille. Paris, 1892.
Hampson N. The Perfidy of Albion. Basingstoke, 1998.
International law concerning the conduct of hostilities: Collection of Hague conventions and some other treaties. Geneva, 1989.
James T. Prisoners of War at Dartmoor: American and French Soldiers and Sailors in an English Prison during the Napoleonic Wars and the War of 1812. Jefferson, NC, 2013.
James Т. Prisoners of war in Dartmoor towns: French and American officers on parole, 1803-1815. Chudleigh, 2000.
Knight R. Convoys. The British Struggle against Napoleonic Europe and America. New Haven, 2022.
Lafon J.-M. L’Andalousie et Napoléon. Contre-insurrection, collaboration et résistances dans le midi de l’Espagne, 1808-1812. Paris, 2007.
Levie H.S. Terrorism in War: The Law of War Crimes. New York, 1993.
Lloyd C.L. A History of Napoleonic and American Prisoners of War, 1756-1816. Woodbridge, Suffolk, 2007.
Lynn J.A. Honourable surrender in early modern European history, 1500-1789. // How Fighting Ends. A History of Surrender / Ed. by H. Afflerbach, H. Strachan. Oxford, 2012.
Macdougall I. All Men are Brethren: Prisoners-of-war in Scotland, 1803-14. Edinburgh, 2008.
Mackenzie S. P. The Treatment of Prisoners of War in World War II // Journal of Modern History. 1994. N 66:3.
Masson P. Les sépulcres flottants : prisonniers français en Angleterre sous l'Empire. Rennes, 1987.
Mikaberidze А. Napoleon’s Lost Legions: The Grande Armée prisoners of war in Russia // Napoleonica. La revue. 2014. N 21:3. P. 35–44.
Morieux R. The Society of Prisoners. Anglo-French Wars and Incarceration in the Eighteenth Century. Cambridge, 2019.
Pickenpaugh R. Captives in Blue. The Civil War Prisons of the Confederacy. Tuscaloosa, 2013.
Prestwich M. Armies and Warfare in the Middle Ages. The English Experience. New Haven, 1996.
Regulations which all prisoners of war are bound to observe. Signed by Joseph Clark, an American prisoner-of-war in Ashburton (Derbyshire). 31 March 1813.
Ribbe С. Le crime de Napoléon. Paris, 2013.
Roberts A. Foundation myths in the Laws of War: The 1863 Lieber Code and the 1864 Geneva Convention // Melbourne Journal of International Law. 2019. N 20:1. P. 158-196.
Rouanet D. Captivités en Russie: regards comparés // 1812 : la campagne de Russie / Ed. par M.-P. Rey, T. Lentz. Paris, 2012.
Rouanet D. Les grognards face à la captivité // Guerres et armées napoléoniennes : nouveaux regards / Éd. par H. Drévillon, B. Fonck, M. Roucaud. Paris, 2013.
Sharrock D. Cavern reveals the inhuman fate of Napoleon’s defeated troops // The Times, 5 December 2022.
Thorp J.T. French Prisoners' Lodges. A brief account of twenty-six Lodges and Chapters of Freemasons, established and conducted by French Prisoners of War in England and elsewhere, between 1756 and 1814. Leicester, 1900.
Towsey M. Imprisoned Reading: French Prisoners of War at the Selkirk Subscription Library, 1811-1814 // Civilians and War in Europe, 1618-1815 / Ed. by E. Charters, E. Rosenhaft, H. Smith. Liverpool, 2012.