For those studying the anti-French popular resistance in Italy during the Napoleonic Wars, the few historical works by contemporary Italian authors of the early 19th century are particularly significant. The author analyzes how the renowned Milanese intellectual Melchiore Gioia (1767–1829) interpreted the phenomenon of popular resistance in Northern Italy. In 1801, Gioia was appointed historiographer of the Cisalpine Republic. Although he was not a professional historian, but a political thinker and economist, in 1805 he published in Milan the historical work «French, Germans, and Russians in Lombardy», in which he described the events in his country in the late 1790s and early 1800s. The arrival of the French in Italy, according to Gioia, contributed to progress in economics, politics, and culture. On the contrary, he believed the Austrian occupation of 1799–1800 was a period of total ruin and social hardship. From this perspective, Gioia also evaluates the Lombard national resistance to the French conquerors, which for him culminated in the uprising in Pavia in May 1796. The author of the article notes that in this case, Gioia acted not as a historian, but as a propagandist. An analysis of the Italian writer's discourse and key conclusions reveals that he was extremely biased in his assessments and made no effort to be objective. Gioia sought to enhance his social status and secure a firm foothold in the hierarchy of the Kingdom of Italy by offering the Italian elite and the French imperial bureaucracy a version of the history of the Cisalpine Republic and the First Austrian Restoration that could serve as the ideological foundation for a new political regime in Italy.
Melchiorre Gioia on the Italian anti-French resistance and the devastation of Lombardy
Mitrofanov Andrei
The study is realized in the State Academic University for the Humanities within the framework of the state task of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Russian Federation (project FZNF–2023–0003 Traditions and values of society: mechanisms of formation and transformation in the context of global history).
References:
Bolt V. S. Italʹianskie insurgenty i armiia A. V. Suvorova v 1799 g. (po rossiĭskim istochnikam) // Frantsuzskiĭ ezhegodnik. 2023. T. 56. S. 141–157.
Zaytseva D. V. Frantsuzy v Neapolitanskoĭ respublike 1799 g. // Frantsuzskiĭ ezhegodnik. 2023. T. 56. S. 97–115.
Mitrofanov A. A., Promyslov N. V., Prusskaia E. A. Rossiia vo frantsuzskoĭ presse perioda Revoliutsii i Napoleonovskikh voĭn (1789–1814) Moscow, 2019.
Mitrofanov A. A. Frantsuzskaia politicheskaia ėlita perioda Revoliutsii XVIII veka o Rossii. Moscow, 2020.
Mitrofanov A. A. Vrazhda i nenavistʹ v Pʹemonte: krestʹianskie vosstaniia 1799 g. v vospriiatii sovremennikov // Ėlektronnyĭ nauchno-obrazovatelʹnyĭ zhurnal «Istoriia». T. 15. Vyp. 6 (140).
Mitrofanov A. A. Khristianskoe voinstvo Brandy Luchoni. Dva veka chernoĭ legendy // Frantsuzskiĭ ezhegodnik. 2023. T. 56. S. 116–140.
Mitrofanov A. A. Ideia «pʹemontskoĭ natsii» v italo-frantsuzskoĭ publitsistike. Patrioticheskaia diskussiia 1799 goda // Dialog so vremenem. 2022. Vyp. 80. S. 253–269.
Tchoudinov A. V. «Soldaty svobody» ili smertelʹnyĭ vrag? Frantsuzy v Iuzhnoĭ Italii 1798—1799 gg. // Izvestiia Uralʹskogo federalʹnogo universiteta. Seriia 2. Gumanitarnye nauki. 2016. № 2. S. 25–41.
Tchoudinov A. V. Vtoraia smertʹ Andreasa Khofera? Osobennosti ėvoliutsii istoricheskoĭ pamiati o Tirolʹskom vosstanii 1809 g. Ėlektronnyĭ nauchno-obrazovatelʹnyĭ zhurnal «Istoriia». 2020. T. 11 Vypusk 4 (90).
Agnoli F. M. Le insorgenze antigiacobine in Italia 1796-1815. Rimini, 2003.
Banti A. M. The nation of the Risorgimento: kinship, sanctity, and honor in the origins of unified Italy. Abingdon, Oxon, New York, 2020.
Catalano F. Melchiorre Gioia e il passagio economico-sociale dal Settecento all’Ottocento // Belfagor. 1950. Vol. 5. № 6. Р. 636–656.
Le insorgenze popolari nell'Italia napoleonica. Crisi dell'antico regime e alternative di costruzione del nuovo ordine sociale / А cura di C. Continisio. Atti del convegno di studio. Milano, 25-26 novembre 1999. Roma, 2001.
Italia Napoleonica. Dizionario critico / A cura di Luigi Mascilli Migliorini. Torino, 2011.
De Francesco A. The antiquity of the Italian nation. The cultural origins of a political myth in modern Italy, 1796–1943. Oxford, 2013.
Folle controrivoluzionarie. Le insorgenze popolari nel l'Italia giacobina e napoleonica / A cura di A. M. Rao. Roma, 1999.
Il Giacobino pentito. Carlo Botta fra Napoleone e Washington. Roma, 2010.
Kerautret M. Eugène de Beauharnais: fils et vice-roi de Napoléon. Paris, 2021.
Sofia F. Melchiorre Gioia. Enciclopedia Treccani. URL: https://www.treccani.it/enciclopedia/melchiorre-gioia_%28Dizionario-Biografico%29/ (Дата обращения: 25.04.2025).
Themelly P. Melchiorre Gioia e la Rivoluzione. Dalle anticipazioni letterarie del Caligola al programma democratico del 1796 // Eurostudium. Riviste Online Sapienza. 2011. № 20. P. 14. URL: https://rosa.uniroma1.it/rosa01/eurostudium/article/view/2270/2051 (Дата обращения: 20.04.2025).
Viglione M. La Vandea Italiana. Le insorgenze controrivoluzionarie dalle origini al 1814. Milano, 1995.
Viglione M. Le insorgenze. Rivoluzione e Controrivoluzione in Italia. 1792–1815. Milano, 1999.
Viglione M. Rivolte dimenticate. Le insorgenze degli italiani dalle origini al 1815. Roma, 1999.
Zaghi C. L'Italia di Napoleone dalla Cisalpina al Regno. Torino, 1986.